Will the member take an intervention?

I welcome the chance to take part in the debate, which comes a day before Derek Mackay unveils his latest spending proposals to a waiting

Will the member take an intervention?

I press the amendment.

I have been slightly concerned throughout this process that—whether it is deliberate or not—ministers do not appear to get the process of

If John Mason thinks that, he should support amendment 15, which says that there should be a review of all charitable reliefs.

The unintended consequence of section 4A would have been students being penalised through an increase in their rents.

The minister has a strange definition of what counts as a U-turn.

The poor returns to assessors when they ask for information are a cause for concern and the level of those returns must improve.

I am disappointed that the minister is not listening to the voice of business on the amendments.